Saturday, June 19, 2010
Guilty as Charged; Caught Red Handed.
In reading the elaborate introduction of Amusing Ourselves to Death by Neil Postman's son, Andrew Postman, I was intrigued by something he indirectly suggested; a media fast. For 24 hours, refrain from electronic media (which I also recall Mrs. Fletcher speaking of a similar idea). I decided to give it a shot, because I strongly believe Huxley and Postman are right in the aspect that this generation is deeply influenced and consumed by media craze. I must admit that even though I am not a big "T.V." person, I am still eaten alive by the media and all it's glamour. "Each student has his or her own weakness-" Postman writes in the early paragraphs of the intro. Do you know how stressful it was for me to wake up in the morning by instinct and not by my always dependable alarm radio? Imagine how I felt when I skipped watching my favorite movies on the IFC last night. And might I mention, I literally felt like pulling out every strand of my eyebrows when I was just ITCHING to play a Fleetwood Mac vinyl or turn the T.V. to the Tennis Channel to catch a glimpse of Rafa Nadal! I thought it would be a piece of apple pie but being so immune to modern day technology and gossip in the media, it was a difficult challenge (and wasn't as sweet as apple pie but more like public-restroom-food-that-fell-on-the-floor-but-you-decide-to-eat-it-anyway kind of pie). It was challenging and I did cheat a little but quickly caught myself. But, here I am, 24 hours later, using a computer (Ahh, the irony.) During the fast I ended up reading half the dictionary, something I would never do if I had that access to the Internet. So after my fasting, I'm beginning to feel that the media hasn't left one thing, one subject, one concept untouched. EVERYthing is exploited. From children on shows such as 'Toddlers in Tiaras' to news stories on more graphic shows like 'To Catch a Predator'. So I raised a question; Do you think us humans would be able to think for ourselves without the media? Could we still continue to function without the medias opinions and or consent? Must we make things such as child abuse, tornadoes and weight loss entertaining by creating reality shows about them? What is so wrong with the written word and speech these days, Is it not powerful enough? I won't share with you my answer to this, not now anyway. Instead, I ask you to please attempt the media fast, and I'll guarantee that if you successfully go 24 official hours without electronic media (this including cell phones, ipods, radio, T.V., computers-Zilch! Nada! None!) then you'll figure out an answer of your own to my wonders.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I have yet to try the 24 hour challenge (I'm scared, I can't go hours without the comforting blue color facebook uses), but I have realized media's control of our minds from day one. But media can't control one thing: human instinct (yet?). People living in the 18th and 19th century had very little media other than the printed newspaper, and they survived. All they thought about was how they were to provide for themselves and their family, basic human instincts. The printed word isn't less powerful per se, but it isn't what the people want. Seeing an explosion is more riveting than reading a description of an explosion. Peoples mind's have slowly evolved into something that wants convenient and condensed information and technology and the media provides just that. I can say I'm thoroughly afraid of the 24 hour challenge, especially since (ironically) I'm reading the electronic eBook version of Brave New World on my computer.
ReplyDeleteSo I think I'm going to go on my technology fast tomorrow which I don't think is going to be so bad since I'm going to be out working with kids all day, but as I'm planning how to avoid media tomorrow I stumbled upon this article from Time, and it got me thinking even more about media. What if there was kill switch for the internet? Would we be able to revert back to how things once were back in the early 80's? After the initial shock and panic of course. I guess the only one we could ask is Ms Fletcher, so I pose this question to you Ms. Fletcher. Do you think you could go back to how it was before when people actually talked to the neighbor down the street rather than their Facebook friend in Germany?
ReplyDeleteOnce you know, how can you un-know? Could we go back to any earlier human society and live by those norms? Like a perpetual Civil War enactment society, except we'd be in the 80s, before the web browser??
ReplyDeleteI guess we could be forced to revert back by some kind of natural disaster, but in that case, losing Facebook would be the least of our worries. We aren't going back...we have to find ways to retain our humanity and live with technology.
There was a book a few years back called Four Arguments for the Elimination of Television. Postman refers to it in one of his later chapters...and he says to make this suggestion is to make no suggestion at all because it's never going to happen.